Camacho & Reinhard stated in the December 2019 issue of the KJP (57: 621-625) that we confused a pollen grain with an Enterobius egg found in the grave of a female adolescent residing in ancient Tehran 7,000 years ago. We want here to clarify and answer to the outlined points in their article.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Paleoparasitology and archaeoparasitology in Iran: A retrospective in differential diagnosis Alireza Sazmand International Journal of Paleopathology.2021; 32: 50. CrossRef
The study of coprolites has been a theme of archaeology in the American Southwest. A feature of archaeoparasitology on the Colorado Plateau is the ubiquity of pinworm infection. As a crowd parasite, this ubiquity signals varying concentrations of populations. Our recent analysis of coprolite deposits from 2 sites revealed the highest prevalence of infection ever recorded for the region. For Salmon Ruins, the deposits date from AD 1140 to 1280. For Aztec Ruins, the samples can be dated by artifact association between AD 1182-1253. Both sites can be placed in the Ancestral Pueblo III occupation (AD 1100-1300), which included a period of cultural stress associated with warfare. Although neither of these sites show evidence of warfare, they are typical of large, defensible towns that survived this time of threat by virtue of large populations in stonewalled villages with easily accessible water. We hypothesize that the concentration of large numbers of people promoted pinworm infection and, therefore, explains the phenomenal levels of infection at these sites.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Is pinworm infection still a public health concern among children in resource-rich regions? Trends in pinworm infection prevalence and associated factors among children in Hualien County, Taiwan: a retrospective cross-sectional study Yu-Chao Hsiao, Jen-Hung Wang, Chia-Hsiang Chu, Yu-Hsun Chang, Yung-Chieh Chang, Rong-Hwa Jan, Shao-Yin Chu, Shang-Hsien Yang, Jui-Shia Chen, Ming-Chun Chen BMC Public Health.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Paleomicrobiology of the human digestive tract: A review Riccardo Nodari, Michel Drancourt, Rémi Barbieri Microbial Pathogenesis.2021; 157: 104972. CrossRef
There is often the risk of confusing pollen grains with helminth eggs from archaeological sites. Thousands to millions of pollen grains can be recovered from archaeological burial sediments that represent past ritual, medication and environment. Some pollen grain types can be similar to parasite eggs. Such a confusion is represented by the diagnosis of enterobiasis in ancient Iran. The authors of this study confused a joint-pine (Ephedra spp.) pollen grain with a pinworm egg. This paper describes the specific Ephedra pollen morphology that can be confused with pinworm eggs.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Detection of Enterobius vermicularis in archived formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) appendectomy blocks: It’s potential to compare genetic variations based on mitochondrial DNA (cox1) gene Maryam Haghshenas, Mona Koosha, Alireza Latifi, Elham Kazemirad, Arash Dehghan, Bahram Nikmanesh, Gholamreza Mowlavi, Ebrahim Shokoohi PLOS ONE.2023; 18(2): e0281622. CrossRef
Comparative study of a broad qPCR panel and centrifugal flotation for detection of gastrointestinal parasites in fecal samples from dogs and cats in the United States Christian M. Leutenegger, Cecilia E. Lozoya, Jeffrey Tereski, Jan Andrews, Kelly D. Mitchell, Cathy Meeks, Jennifer L. Willcox, Gregory Freeman, Holly L. Richmond, Christian Savard, Michelle D. Evason Parasites & Vectors.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
A novel use of a geometric morphometric technique to distinguish human parasite eggs of twelve different species Nantana Suwandittakul, Mathirut Mungthin, Kewarin Kuntawong, Sedthapong Laojun, Siripong Pimsuka, Tanawat Chaiphongpachara Experimental Parasitology.2022; 238: 108281. CrossRef
The development of an artificial intelligence-based digital pathology for neglected tropical diseases: A platform specific analysis of the World Health Organization diagnostic target product profile for soil-transmitted helminthiasis Peter Ward, Lindsay A. Broadfield, Peter Dahlberg, Gemechu Leta, Zeleke Mekonnen, Betty Nabatte, Narcis Kabatereine, Alan Brooks, Kristina M. Orrling, Mireille Gomes, Sofie Van Hoecke, Bruno Levecke, Lieven J. Stuyver Frontiers in Tropical Diseases.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Paleoparasitology and archaeoparasitology in Iran: A retrospective in differential diagnosis Alireza Sazmand International Journal of Paleopathology.2021; 32: 50. CrossRef
Paleomicrobiology of the human digestive tract: A review Riccardo Nodari, Michel Drancourt, Rémi Barbieri Microbial Pathogenesis.2021; 157: 104972. CrossRef
Attempting to simplify methods in parasitology of archaeological sediments: An examination of taphonomic aspects Aida Romera Barbera, Darwin Hertzel, Karl J. Reinhard Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports.2020; 33: 102522. CrossRef
Investigations of Enterobius sp. infection in prehistory have produced a body of data that can be used to evaluate the geographic distribution of infection through time in the Americas. Regional variations in prevalence are evident. In North America, 119 pinworm positive samples were found in 1,112 samples from 28 sites with a prevalence of 10.7%. Almost all of the positive samples came from agricultural sites. From Brazil, 0 pinworm positive samples were found in 325 samples from 7 sites. For the Andes region, 22 pinworm positive samples were found in 411 samples from 26 sites for a prevalence of 5.3%. Detailed analyses of these data defined several trends. First, preagricultural sites less frequently show evidence of infection compared to agricultural populations. This is especially clear in the data from North America, but is also evident in the data from South America. Second, there is an apparent relationship between the commonality of pinworms in coprolites and the manner of constructing villages. These analyses show that ancient parasitism has substantial value in documenting the range of human behaviors that influence parasitic infections.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
A New Approach in Investigation the Chemotaxis Response of Mammalian Parasitic Nematode: In Vitro Study Nahla A. Radwan, Walid Tawfik, Diaa Atta, Mohamed F. Ageba, Saly N. Salama, Mohamed N. Mohamed Journal of Experimental Zoology Part A: Ecological and Integrative Physiology.2025; 343(6): 650. CrossRef
Enhanced object detection of Enterobius vermicularis eggs using cumulative transfer learning algorithm Pongphan Pongpanitanont, Naparat Suttidate, Hiroshi Yamasaki, Wanchai Maleewong, Penchom Janwan PeerJ Computer Science.2025; 11: e3213. CrossRef
Intestinal parasites from Hubei archaeological sites of early China (5th century BCE to 3rd century CE) Xiaoya Zhan, Mi Zhou, Qun Zhang, Hui-Yuan Yeh Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports.2024; 58: 104734. CrossRef
Enterobiasis and its risk factors in urban, rural and indigenous children of subtropical Argentina Maria Romina Rivero, Carlos De Angelo, Constanza Feliziani, Song Liang, Karina Tiranti, Martin Miguel Salas, Oscar Daniel Salomon Parasitology.2022; 149(3): 396. CrossRef
Pinworm research in the Southwest USA: five decades of methodological and theoretical development and the epidemiological approach Morgana Camacho, Karl J. Reinhard Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
The what, how and why of archaeological coprolite analysis Lisa-Marie Shillito, John C. Blong, Eleanor J. Green, Eline N. van Asperen Earth-Science Reviews.2020; 207: 103196. CrossRef
First report in pre-Columbian mummies from Bolivia of Enterobius vermicularis infection and capillariid eggs: A contribution to Paleoparasitology studies Guido Valverde, Viterman Ali, Pamela Durán, Luis Castedo, José Luis Paz, Eddy Martínez International Journal of Paleopathology.2020; 31: 34. CrossRef
Intestinal helminths as a biomolecular complex in archaeological research Patrik G. Flammer, Adrian L. Smith Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.2020; 375(1812): 20190570. CrossRef
Intestinal Parasitic Infection in the Eastern Roman Empire During the Imperial Period and Late Antiquity Marissa L. Ledger, Erica Rowan, Frances Gallart Marques, John H. Sigmier, Nataša Šarkić, Saša Redžić, Nicholas D. Cahill, Piers D. Mitchell American Journal of Archaeology.2020; 124(4): 631. CrossRef
Pinworm Infection at Salmon Ruins and Aztec Ruins: Relation to Pueblo III Regional Violence Karl J Reinhard, Morgana Camacho The Korean Journal of Parasitology.2019; 57(6): 627. CrossRef
Confusing a Pollen Grain with a Parasite Egg: an Appraisal of “Paleoparasitological Evidence of Pinworm (Enterobius Vermicularis) Infection in a Female Adolescent Residing in Ancient Tehran” Morgana Camacho, Karl J. Reinhard The Korean Journal of Parasitology.2019; 57(6): 621. CrossRef
The Diagnosis and Treatment of Pinworm Infection Sebastian Wendt, Henning Trawinski, Stefan Schubert, Arne C. Rodloff, Joachim Mössner, Christoph Lübbert Deutsches Ärzteblatt international.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Recovering parasites from mummies and coprolites: an epidemiological approach Morgana Camacho, Adauto Araújo, Johnica Morrow, Jane Buikstra, Karl Reinhard Parasites & Vectors.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
The Paleoepidemiology ofEnterobius vermicularis(Nemata: Oxyuridae) Among the Loma San Gabriel at La Cueva de los Muertos Chiquitos (600–800 CE), Rio Zape Valley, Durango, Mexico Johnica J. Morrow, Karl J. Reinhard Comparative Parasitology.2018; 85(1): 27. CrossRef
Taphonomic considerations on pinworm prevalence in three Ancestral Puebloan latrines Morgana Camacho, Alena Mayo Iñiguez, Karl Jan Reinhard Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports.2018; 20: 791. CrossRef
Acidic mammalian chitinase tuning after enteric helminths eradication in inflammatory respiratory disease patients Marwa A. Hasby Saad, Mona Watany, Mohamed Tomoum, Dalia El‐Mehy, May Elsheikh, Ragia Sharshar Parasite Immunology.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
The prevalence of Enterobius vermicularis infection among preschool children was reported to be low based on a 5-year screening program in Taipei City, Taiwan. The Taipei City government intended to terminate the E. vermicularis screening program among preschool children. Thus, we were entrusted with confirming whether pinworm infections among preschool children in Taipei City had truly declined. From each of 12 administrative districts 2-3 kindergartens were randomly selected for investigation. In total, 4,349 children were examined, of which 2,537 were boys and 1,812 were girls. The cellophane tape adhered to a glass slide was used, and all examinations were done by certified medical technologists. Results indicated that the overall prevalence rate of pinworm infections was 0.62% (27/4,349). Although the infection rate was higher among boys (0.67%, 17/2,537) than in girls (0.55%, 10/1,812), no significant difference was found (χ2 = 0.399, P = 0.62). According to the administrative district, the infection rate ranged from no positive cases of E. vermicularis infection in the Xinyi, Zhongzhen, and Wanhua Districts (0%; 0/299, 0/165, and 0/358, respectively), to 0.26% (1/131) in Songshan District, with the highest rate of 1.88% (7/373) in Wenshan District. Because the overall infection rate (0.62%, 27/4,349) in the present study was unchanged compared to that (0.40%, 197/49,541) previously reported in 2005, we propose that regular pinworm screening and treatment programs should be continued in some parts of Taipei City.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Enterobius vermicularis infection and its risk factors among rural schoolchildren in Zhejiang Province: a cross-sectional study Jialie Jin, Wei Ruan, Wenjie Xu, Xuan Zhang, Kegen Yu, Hualiang Chen, Jiaqi Zhang, Jimin Sun, Jianmin Jiang, Xiaoxiao Wang Parasitology Research.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Pinworm (Enterobius Vermicularis) Infestation: An Updated Review Alexander K.C. Leung, Joseph M. Lam, Benjamin Barankin, Alex H.C. Wong, Kin F. Leong, Kam L. Hon Current Pediatric Reviews.2025; 21(4): 333. CrossRef
Pinworm infection in school children of four districts of Malakand region, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan W. Khan, W. A. Panhwar, S. A. Mehmood, S. Ahmed, M. S. Ahmed, N. Khan, M. M. Khan, W. Akram, S. Ullah, Imran Brazilian Journal of Biology.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Enterobiasis among Yemeni children: a cross-sectional study Abdulelah H. Al-Adhroey, Yahya A. Al-Ansi, Mohammed A. Al-Kholani, Abdulrahman H. Amer, Marwan M. Al-Khyat, Fadia H. Al Hubaishi, Radhwan H. Aziz, Ebrahim S. Al-Khateeb, Souad A. Al-Gabri, Tawfik M. Al-Gabri Journal of Parasitic Diseases.2022; 46(3): 722. CrossRef
Investigation of the Prevalence of Enterobius Vermicularis Infection and Risk Factors among Kindergartens in Hamadan, West of Iran, in 2019 Mohammad Fallah, Mahdi Parsaei, Eissa Soleymani, Ali Jamshidizad, Afshin Azimi Avicenna Journal of Clinical Medicine.2022; 28(4): 253. CrossRef
Is pinworm infection still a public health concern among children in resource-rich regions? Trends in pinworm infection prevalence and associated factors among children in Hualien County, Taiwan: a retrospective cross-sectional study Yu-Chao Hsiao, Jen-Hung Wang, Chia-Hsiang Chu, Yu-Hsun Chang, Yung-Chieh Chang, Rong-Hwa Jan, Shao-Yin Chu, Shang-Hsien Yang, Jui-Shia Chen, Ming-Chun Chen BMC Public Health.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Epidemiologic Study of Enterobius vermicularis Infection among Schoolchildren in the Republic of Marshall Islands Chia-Kwung Fan, Pasaikou Sonko, Yueh-Lun Lee, Ai-Wen Yin, Ting-Wu Chuang, Ramson Kios, Ying-Ting Wang, Chia-Mei Chou, Shao-Lun Hsu, Mai-Szu Wu, Jia-Wei Lin, Chia-Ying Tu, Pedro P. Chieffi Journal of Tropical Medicine.2021; 2021: 1. CrossRef
Prevalencia y variables asociadas a la transmisión de Enterobius vermicularis en niños en edad preescolar y escolar en dos municipios de Cundinamarca, Colombia Julio Cesar Giraldo Forero, Laura Catalina Rodríguez Fonseca, Lina Maria Pinzón Triana, Valentina Vega Díaz Revista Med.2020; 27(1): 17. CrossRef
Prevalence of Enterobius vermicularis infections and associated risk factors among schoolchildren in Nakhon Si Thammarat, Thailand Pokkamol Laoraksawong, Pimyada Pansuwan, Supakrit Krongchon, Pongphan Pongpanitanont, Penchom Janwan Tropical Medicine and Health.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Pinworm infections associated with risk of psychiatric disorders-A nationwide cohort study in Taiwan Pei-Chun Chao, Wu-Chien Chien, Chi-Hsiang Chung, Ching-Wen Chu, Chin-Bin Yeh, Hsin-An Chang, Yu-Chen Kao, Hui-Wen Yeh, Wei-Shan Chiang, Nian-Sheng Tzeng Comprehensive Psychiatry.2019; 93: 14. CrossRef
Gene-based molecular characterization of cox1 and pnad5 in Hymenolepis nana isolated from naturally infected mice and rats in Saudi Arabia Dina M. Metwally, Huda A. Al-Enezy, Isra M. Al-Turaiki, Manal F. El-Khadragy, Hany M. Yehia, Tahani T. Al-Otaibi Bioscience Reports.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Prevalence, Morphological and Molecular Phylogenetic Analyses of the Rabbit Pinworm, Passalurus ambiguus Rudolphi 1819, in the Domestic Rabbits Oryctolagus cuniculus Rewaida Abdel-Gaber, Farid Ataya, Dalia Fouad, Mohamed Daoud, Shatha Alzuhairy Acta Parasitologica.2019; 64(2): 316. CrossRef
Enterobius vermicularis infection: prevalence and risk factors among preschool children in kindergarten in the capital area, Republic of the Marshall Islands Chia-Kwung Fan, Ting-Wu Chuang, Ying-Chieh Huang, Ai-Wen Yin, Chia-Mei Chou, Yu-Ting Hsu, Ramson Kios, Shao-Lun Hsu, Ying-Ting Wang, Mai-Szu Wu, Jia-Wei Lin, Kennar Briand, Chia-Ying Tu BMC Infectious Diseases.2019;[Epub] CrossRef
Enterobius vermicularis infection and its risk factors among pre-school children in Taipei, Taiwan Kuang-Yao Chen, Chuan-Min Yen, Kao-Pin Hwang, Lian-Chen Wang Journal of Microbiology, Immunology and Infection.2018; 51(4): 559. CrossRef
A preliminary epidemiological study of pinworm infection in Thaklong Municipal Early Childhood Development Center and Rangsit Babies’ Home, Pathum Thani, Thailand Aree Taylor, Prasert Saichua, Pochong Rhongbutsri, Rattana Tiengtip, Sirima Kitvatanachai, Walter R. J. Taylor BMC Research Notes.2018;[Epub] CrossRef
Morphological Re-Description and 18 S rDNA Sequence Confirmation of the Pinworm Aspiculuris tetraptera (Nematoda, Heteroxynematidae) Infecting the Laboratory Mice Mus musculus
Rewaida Abdel-Gaber, Fathy Abdel-Ghaffar, Saleh Al Quraishy, Kareem Morsy, Rehab Saleh, Heinz Mehlhorn Journal of Nematology.2018; 50(2): 117. CrossRef
Microbiome and mental health in the modern environment Emily Deans Journal of Physiological Anthropology.2017;[Epub] CrossRef
Prevalence ofEnterobius vermicularisamong Children in Iran: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis Mahmood Moosazadeh, Ghasem Abedi, Mahdi Afshari, Seif Ali Mahdavi, Fereshteh Farshidi, Elham Kheradmand Osong Public Health and Research Perspectives.2017; 8(2): 108. CrossRef
Impact of Enterobius vermicularis infection and mebendazole treatment on intestinal microbiota and host immune response Chin-An Yang, Chao Liang, Chia-Li Lin, Chiung-Tzu Hsiao, Ching-Tien Peng, Hung-Chih Lin, Jan-Gowth Chang, Makedonka Mitreva PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases.2017; 11(9): e0005963. CrossRef
Prevalence of Enterobius vermicularis Among Children in Kindergartens and Primary Schools in Iran: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Mahmood Moosazadeh, Ghasem Abedi, Mahdi Afshari, Seif Ali Mahdavi, Fereshteh Farshidi, Elham Kheradmand Osong Public Health and Research Perspectives.2016;[Epub] CrossRef
Risk factors for Enterobius vermicularis infection in children in Gaozhou, Guangdong, China Hong-Mei Li, Chang-Hai Zhou, Zhi-Shi Li, Zhuo-Hui Deng, Cai-Wen Ruan, Qi-Ming Zhang, Ting-Jun Zhu, Long-Qi Xu, Ying-Dan Chen Infectious Diseases of Poverty.2015;[Epub] CrossRef
Enterobius vermicularis and Risk Factors in Healthy Norwegian Children Håkon Bøås, German Tapia, John A. Sødahl, Trond Rasmussen, Kjersti S. Rønningen Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal.2012; 31(9): 927. CrossRef
Enterobius vermicularis infection is well controlled among preschool children in nurseries of Taipei City, Taiwan Tu-Bin Chu, Chien-Wei Liao, Takeshi Nara, Ying-Chie Huang, Chia-Mei Chou, Yu-Hsin Liu, Chia-Kwung Fan Revista da Sociedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical.2012; 45(5): 646. CrossRef
First
Prev
